Showing posts with label mark gatiss. Show all posts
Showing posts with label mark gatiss. Show all posts

Sunday, 11 June 2017

Doctor Who: Empress of Mars

A reptilian queen from 1881 tries to impose her will on the masses without mandate…how topical.


This episode is a welcome surprise. It’s far better than it’s trailer made out, largely because it’s trailer neglected the B story (which is incidentally more significant than the a story).

The A story sees the Doctor and Bill stranded on Mars in 1881, with a battalion of British troops, who have declared Mars part of the Empire and an Ice Warrior who claims to be the last of his kind. Right from the off you can pretty much see where it’s going, but it still remains fun to watch.

The B story focuses on Nardole as the TARDIS decides to reverse to the Doctor’s study and park there refusing to move.

Nardole is eventually forced to go to Missy for help in getting it working again. Like I said, the strength of this story is that it was left out of trailer. It works to kill two birds, but removing the Doctor’s easy escape route and building on the suspicion surrounding Missy.  She has the know-how to remotely control the TARDIS, but also pilots it back to save the Doctor and seems concerned about him. The downside to this, is that it’s completely out of character for Nardole to go to Missy for help. He’s berated the Doctor for leaving Missy’s cell unguarded for a matter of hours; it’s difficult to see him releasing her for any reason regardless of the stakes. It would have made more sense for Bill to have been the one to let her out as she’s the least cautious around Missy. On that point, aside from a female empowerment moment, Bill is slightly wasted in the A plot; she really doesn’t have anything to do besides exist.

The titular Empress of Mars is good as both a character and villain. Once again, the writers make it slightly political by having a female ruler who’s (literally) disconnected from the age in which she’s operating and in desperate need of figuring out how to get along with others.

Overall, this is a fun (politically satirical) episode, but the B story comes across as far more significant than the A.



Sunday, 15 November 2015

Doctor Who: Sleep no More

Err that was ok.


I’ve never been 100% on board with Mark Gatiss; his work on Sherlock is pretty good, but his Who scripts have been largely unfulfilling. He’s a good writer, but I’ve never really seen why people have him pegged as the next Executive Producer of Doctor Who.

This episode is the first hint that he might be up to the job. It’s a bit like Moffat creating the Weeping Angles or the crack in time out of something that crops up in every day life; namely, sleep.

The monsters are made of sleep dust…ok. Once you get past the initial silliness of that principle, the episode is alright.

I had no love for the found footage method of shooting, until Gatiss worked it into the story, both with the explanation of why it was there and the twist at the end. That was neat; it stopped it from just being a gimmick.

The supporting cast are fleshed out and not and Capaldi and Coleman are on usual form, particularly when they have to talk directly to the camera.

It’s not without fault; the basic principle is that anyone who has been inside the Morpheus machine gets a point-of-view camera installed in the corner of their eye. That’s all very well, but I’m fairly sure we see plenty from Chopra’s perspective, when it’s made clear that he’s never used the machine. They do make an effort to make his perspective more of a helmet cam than a point of view. But why would he have a helmet cam when none one else in the rescue team did?

Also, the twist at the end kind of just rips off The Ring, without any explanation of how it works and the episode in general is quite slow until about ten minutes in.


Aside from that it’s perfectly serviceable; a nice improvement from last week.

Sunday, 7 September 2014

Doctor Who: The Robot of Sherwood

Well that was ok….


I’m never really on board with these kinds of episodes. Bringing Robin Hood into Who is a gateway to reach stupid levels of cheese, that threaten to undermine the shows point more than that Power of Three Episode and most of Series 2 combined.

Thankfully, while this episode does have some of that, Mark Gatiss manages to turn most of it on itself.

Tom Riley is doing a good job as Robin Hood, but as the Doctor even points out, men like this never existed. It would have been nice to see some shaking up of the character, if they were going to make him “real”. Take away some of the heroism, add some selfishness or something.

Ben Miller is also putting in a good performance as the Sheriff of Nottingham, with subtle comedic turns, based around him being a moron.

Clara just about stays in character, but her interrogation scene is a bit silly and risks sending her into Amy Pond levels of writer-personality tampering. Personally, I like Clara as a character and I’m not sure why many viewers don’t. Most of what she does is based around things that have already been established about her, rather than things that any given writer could add at any given time. However, the Clara suddenly knows Taekwondo bit is straying into that territory.

On that point, the Twelfth Doctor is like the Third in more in more than just dress sense, as he wins a sword fight with a spoon, at the cost of one of his buttons of course. I like the idea of this Doctor knowing how to fight, especially since it lends something to the “did he throw that guy out of that airship?” question from the first episode.

Soo, have you noticed what’s missing yet? Despite being the primary antagonists, the robots in this episode aren’t very well fleshed out. For the moment I’m hoping (since they’re going to The Promised Land) that that’s an intentional move. It could be that only robots who are dogmatic in their intention to get there are actually able to.

All in all it was good, a few missed opportunities, but a solid writer at the helm saw that a dangerously cheesey premise didn’t get out of hand.